Cigar Box Manhattan: The Smoky, Spiced Whisper of the Speakeasy

The Cigar Box Manhattan (also known as Smoked Manhattan) is a sultry, oak-scented reinvention of one of the most iconic whiskey cocktails ever created. Where the classic Manhattan celebrates whiskey and vermouth in equal measure, the Cigar Box version introduces smoke, spice, and subtle tannin—a refined nod to leather chairs, old books, and the curling aroma of a freshly opened humidor.

This cocktail doesn’t literally include cigars, but it evokes them through ingredients that suggest their essence: barrel-aged bitters, spiced vermouth, smoky rinse, and sometimes even a quick infusion of cedar or tobacco-scented elements. It’s an experience built for slow sipping, ideally in low light, with jazz playing faintly in the background.

I discovered this style while visiting a craft cocktail bar in Montreal, where they smoked their Manhattans in cedar boxes and used vermouths aged in ex-wine barrels. The balance of bittersweetness and aromatic smoke instantly conjured images of velvet lounges and whispered secrets. The Cigar Box Manhattan has been in my rotation ever since—equal parts ceremony and sophistication.

---

Quick Facts: Cigar Box Manhattan

Method: stirred
Flavor profile: smoky, spiced, bitter-sweet
How to serve it: up or over large ice
Glassware: coupe or rocks glass
Alcohol content: ~26–28% ABV, ~21–24 grams of alcohol per serving

---

Ingredients

• 2 oz rye or bourbon whiskey (see notes)
• 1 oz sweet vermouth (preferably aged or spiced)
• 2 dashes barrel-aged or aromatic bitters
• Optional: 1 dash tobacco or mole bitters
• Optional: mezcal rinse or cedar smoke
• Garnish: cherry, expressed orange peel, or cedar-smoked cinnamon stick
• Ice (for stirring)

Recommended Spirits:

Whiskey:

• Rittenhouse Rye – bold and spicy
• Woodford Reserve Bourbon – smooth and oaky
• Michter’s Rye or High West Double Rye – for richness and bite
• Avoid overly sweet or soft bourbons—the smoke and vermouth need backbone

Vermouth:

• Carpano Antica Formula – rich and vanilla-laced
• Punt e Mes – slightly bitter and robust
• Dolin Rouge – lighter but with nuance
• Bonus: try barrel-aged vermouth if you can find it

---

Equipment Needed

• Mixing glass
• Bar spoon
• Jigger
• Strainer
• Coupe or rocks glass
• Torch or cedar plank (for smoke)
• Atomizer (optional, for mezcal or smoke rinse)
• Tongs and tweezers (for garnishing finesse)

The Cigar Box Manhattan relies as much on aroma and presentation as it does on taste. A smoke element—either in the glass or on the garnish—is essential to capturing the full concept.

---

Step-by-Step Instructions

1. Optional: smoke your glass.
Use a cedar plank and torch to generate smoke. Invert your serving glass over the smoke and let it rest for 10–15 seconds. Alternatively, rinse with a touch of mezcal or smoky Scotch.

2. Combine ingredients in mixing glass.
Add to mixing glass:

• 2 oz rye or bourbon
• 1 oz sweet vermouth
• 2 dashes bitters (plus optional dash of mole or tobacco bitters)

3. Stir with ice.
Fill mixing glass with ice and stir for 25–30 seconds, until thoroughly chilled and diluted.

4. Strain and serve.
Strain into your smoked coupe (if served up) or over a large cube in a rocks glass.

5. Garnish with character.

• Express orange peel over the top and discard or drop in
• Or garnish with a brandied cherry on a cedar skewer
• For full effect, rest a smoking cinnamon stick across the rim

Serve and sip slowly.

---

Flavor Profile and Tasting Notes

The Cigar Box Manhattan layers bitterness, sweetness, smoke, and spice with precision. It’s strong but smooth, intense but elegant.

What you’ll taste:

• Deep whiskey warmth with spicy top notes
• Herbal and vanilla undertones from vermouth
• Aromatic bitters blending cocoa, clove, and oak
• Soft smoke on the finish—either subtle or bold, depending on your method

The drink has long legs, meaning it lingers on the palate and evolves as it warms. A cocktail that asks to be contemplated, not rushed.

Pairs beautifully with:

• A fine cigar (if that’s your thing)
• Dark chocolate and sea salt
• Charcuterie with dried fruits and aged cheeses
• Roasted nuts or candied walnuts
• Espresso or strong black tea on the side

---

Garnishing and Presentation

The Cigar Box Manhattan is as much about mood and mystique as it is flavor.

Presentation tips:

• Use a chilled coupe for elegance or a cut crystal rocks glass for weight
• Smoke the glass with cedar, cherry wood, or pipe tobacco (no inhaling, just aroma)
• Add a smoking garnish, like a torched cinnamon stick or clove-studded orange peel
• Use a branded cherry, skewered on a mini cigar box pick or vintage toothpick

Optional: serve the drink in a mini wooden box filled with cinnamon bark and cloves for full effect. Reveal at the table for dramatic flair.

---

Pairing Suggestions

The deep, smoky elements of this cocktail open the door for rich, savory, and bitter-sweet pairings.

Savory:

• Seared duck breast with cherry compote
• Blue cheese or gorgonzola on rye crisps
• Grilled portobello mushrooms
• Lamb chops with rosemary
• Smoked almonds or marcona nuts

Sweet:

• 70–80% dark chocolate
• Cherry clafoutis
• Salted caramel tart
• Tiramisu with a dusting of cocoa
• Pipe tobacco ice cream (yes, it exists)

---

Cocktail History and Trivia

The Manhattan is one of the oldest known cocktails, dating back to the 1860s. Its original form—rye, vermouth, bitters—has remained virtually unchanged for over a century, though countless variations have emerged.

The Cigar Box variation is a modern invention, driven by the recent trend of aromatic, multisensory cocktails. Bartenders began incorporating smoke, cedar, tobacco bitters, and barrel-aging to elevate and personalize their Manhattans.

Cigar Box-style cocktails nod to the luxury and ritual of cigar lounges, without the actual tobacco. Instead, they suggest the experience through flavor notes, aroma, and storytelling—creating cocktails that are immersive and evocative.

---

Serving Suggestions

Serve the Cigar Box Manhattan:

• After dinner, in place of a dessert or digestif
• At a whiskey tasting or cigar night
• As a signature cocktail for intimate events or weddings
• With dessert, especially chocolate or caramel-based treats

Want to impress? Present it tableside in a smoke-filled box or decanter. Let the smoke drift across the table as you pour.

To serve a group:

• Pre-batch the drink in a bottle (2:1 ratio of whiskey to vermouth with bitters)
• Store chilled and pour over ice or serve up with garnish
• Smoke the glasses just before serving for maximum aroma

---

Alcohol Content and Alternatives

The Cigar Box Manhattan runs strong at ~26–28% ABV, owing to its all-spirit build and minimal dilution.

To reduce ABV:

• Use lower-proof whiskey
• Add a splash of club soda for a highball-style drink (technically no longer a Manhattan, but still delicious)

Mocktail version:

• 1 oz pomegranate juice
• 1 oz spiced black tea concentrate
• ½ oz cherry or cinnamon syrup
• Dash of orange or chocolate bitters (non-alcoholic)
  Stir over ice, strain into smoked glass, and garnish with orange peel or cherry.

Variations:

• Tobacco Manhattan: add a few drops of tobacco bitters
• Rum Manhattan: sub in aged rum for whiskey
• Mezcal Box: swap whiskey for mezcal and vermouth for sweet sherry

---

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Does it contain actual tobacco or cigars?
No! The “cigar box” flavor is evoked using smoked wood, bitters, and presentation—not tobacco.

How do I smoke a cocktail at home?
Use a torch and cedar plank, or buy a cocktail smoking kit. You can also rinse the glass with mezcal or smoky Scotch.

Can I batch this cocktail?
Absolutely. Mix in a bottle: 2 parts whiskey, 1 part vermouth, and bitters. Keep chilled and stir to order.

What bitters work best?
Aromatic bitters, mole bitters, or wood-aged bitters. Tobacco or clove bitters add even more cigar-box essence.

How long does vermouth last?
Open vermouth should be refrigerated and used within 1–2 months for best flavor.

---

---

Conclusion

The Cigar Box Manhattan is not just a cocktail—it’s an experience. A bold reinterpretation of a beloved classic, it brings together timeless structure, modern technique, and a deep sensory journey. Whether you’re a seasoned whiskey drinker or a curious explorer, this cocktail promises to transport you with every smoky, spiced sip.